CASE STUDY · COMMERCIAL OFFICE

Chiller plant optimization at Charter Hall's GPO Exchange, Adelaide

Savings on top of an existing central plant optimization (CPO) platform. Chiller staging, load balancing across series-counterflow PowerPax chiller pairs and dynamic condenser water control cut plant energy 8.8% over 12 months, and 10.3% once a condenser water implementation issue was corrected.

GPO Exchange, 10 Franklin Street, Adelaide
5.5-star NABERS Energy office building at the time of the project
Client
Charter Hall
Location
Adelaide, Australia
Sector
Commercial office
Plant
4 × 615 kWr PowerPax
Implementation
November 2022

Energy saving

8.8%

Over the 12-month reporting period, against the adjusted baseline

After the fix

10.3%

From 20 February 2023, after a condenser water algorithm correction

Energy saved

13,005kWh

November 2022 to October 2023

Cost savings

$2,860

Over the 12 months, at $0.22/kWh

The challenge

GPO Exchange is a Charter Hall office building in Adelaide's CBD, rated 5.5 stars for NABERS Energy at the time of the project. Its chiller plant already had a central plant optimization (CPO) platform installed. The question was whether a model of this specific plant could find savings the existing platform wasn't capturing.

The plant has four Smardt PowerPax chillers of 615 kWr each, arranged as a lead pair and a lag pair. Each pair has an upstream and a downstream chiller in a series-counterflow arrangement. In this layout the load split between the two machines in a pair sets each chiller's lift, so balancing load between them is a practical lever. In parallel plants it's harder to hold conditions while balancing load.

The saving came from strategy alone. The chillers, the controls and the CPO platform all stayed in place.

Site profile

Client
Charter Hall
Building
GPO Exchange, 10 Franklin Street, Adelaide SA
Engagement
Through CBRE
Chillers
4 × Smardt PowerPax, 615 kWr each (2,460 kWr)
Arrangement
Lead and lag pairs, each with an upstream and a downstream chiller in series counterflow
Cooling towers
5 × 17 kW
Existing controls
Central plant optimization (CPO) platform
Implementation
November 2022, by Smardt in the existing controls
M&V protocol
IPMVP Option B
Capital expenditure
Nil, software-only engagement
Carbon factor
0.26 tCO2e/MWh (NGA Factors 2025, South Australia, scope 2 and 3)
Tariff
$0.22/kWh
Strategies changed
Chiller staging
Load balancing between upstream and downstream chillers
Dynamic condenser water temperature control

Verified results

12 months of measurement and verification

The baseline ran from 27 June 2021 to 26 June 2022 (245 days with active cooling). The reporting period ran from 7 November 2022 to 30 October 2023 (284 days with active cooling). Daily plant energy was modeled against daily cooling delivered and weighted average system lift, which is the gap between chilled water supply temperature and outdoor wet-bulb temperature, weighted by cooling load. Carbon uses 0.26 tCO2e/MWh, the NGA Factors 2025 figure for South Australia (0.22 scope 2 plus 0.04 scope 3). Cost savings use $0.22/kWh.

OutcomeVerified resultStatus
Energy saving8.8%: 135,005 kWh measured against an adjusted baseline of 148,010 kWhVerified
Energy saved13,005 kWh over the 12-month reporting periodVerified
Energy saving after correction10.3% from 20 February 2023 to the end of the reporting periodVerified, part period
Carbon reduced3.4 tCO2e over the 12 monthsVerified
Cost savings$2,860 over the 12 monthsVerified
Baseline model fitAdjusted R² = 0.981Verified

Verified: measured under IPMVP Option B against the plant's own baseline. Carbon and cost are calculated from the verified kWh at the factor and tariff stated above.

The Exergenics approach

A strategy the chiller manufacturer implemented in the existing controls

Exergenics doesn't write to the BMS. The optimized strategy was issued as a functional description, and Smardt implemented it in the plant's existing controls in November 2022.

1

Model the plant on its own data

Plant trend data came from the building's data warehousing platform. The facilities team flagged plant nuances that don't appear in trend data, and Exergenics adjusted the modeling constraints to match.

2

Generate the strategy

The model set chiller staging, the load split between the upstream and downstream chiller in each series-counterflow pair, and a dynamic condenser water temperature setpoint.

3

Implementation by Smardt

Smardt commissioned the updated control strategy in the existing controls in November 2022. No hardware was added.

4

Monitor and correct

Ongoing monitoring found an issue in how the condenser water algorithm had been implemented. It was corrected in February 2023, and the saving from 20 February 2023 onward was 10.3%.

See what your plant could still save

Exergenics finds savings in chilled water plants that are already well run, including plants with an existing optimization platform. No capital expenditure and no new hardware.

Verified figures come from the 12-month measurement and verification report for GPO Exchange, covering November 2022 to October 2023.